Paris: French activists and lawmakers are demanding that authorities suspend the use of tear gas to disperse crowds following recent street protests, citing concerns that it may cause menstrual changes and other reproductive health problems, though scientists have not confirmed a medical connection.
The demands come after police used tear gas during student protests and demonstrations over the cost of living, some marred by violence. Several women reported painful cramps, unexpected bleeding and disrupted menstrual cycles after exposure. An advocacy group says it has collected more than 10,000 complaints. Opposition lawmakers are seeking a ban and independent research into possible health effects.
Interior Minister Laurent Nunez has rejected the calls, saying police use of tear gas is essential to crowd control as an alternative to more dangerous weapons.
Tear gas grenades used by French police contain CS, a chemical irritant that affects the eyes, skin and respiratory tract. CS is a crystalline powder dispersed into the air as fine particles. Its effects depend on how much is used and how long people are exposed to it.
Those exposed during the protests include peaceful demonstrators, children, pregnant women and older people, as well as residents near the sites of protest marches.
Melina Galland, 24, was working as an independent photographer during October 17 protests in Paris that were marred by rioting and looting. She wore a double surgical mask along with a diving mask when tear gas grenades were fired.
“Heading back home, I felt intense belly pain which was unusual because I never experience pain that intense at that stage of my period,” she said.
Chloe Baroux, 25, also a photographer, first noticed pain and irregular periods after covering protests against a security bill in 2020 and 2021. She said her menstrual cycles eventually became more regular, and she didn't think of a potential link to tear gas until she covered the recent protests, noting, “over the past two months, it's become irregular again.”
Eva-Luna Tholance, a former journalist who investigated the issue six years ago, founded the ‘Lacrymos de sang’ (‘Tears of blood’) advocacy group during the protests to raise awareness about possible effects on menstrual cycles and pregnancies.
The group asked people last month to complete a questionnaire describing their exposure and symptoms. The accounts do not establish how common these symptoms are among people exposed to tear gas and have not been reviewed by independent doctors.
Still, Tholance said many women described pain or unexpected bleeding, with reports ranging from mild cramps to severe pain and bleeding that lasted for weeks.
Some also reported bleeding despite being postmenopausal or taking hormonal contraception that normally prevents menstrual bleeding, she said.
An Associated Press investigation during the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests in the US found limited study and oversight of tear gas, though it raised concerns about exposure in confined spaces, excessive use and canisters fired directly at people.
A recent study collected accounts of symptoms reported after the BLM protests. It found a ‘potential relationship’ between exposure and ‘adverse reproductive health outcomes’ but did not prove cause and effect.
The study relied on self-reported information collected at one point in time, meaning people who felt most affected may have been more likely to respond.
“There's a lot of theories. We don't really 100 per cent know,” said the study's lead author, Asha Hassan of the University of Minnesota Medical School. The study calls for more research ‘urgently.’
Hassan said much early research on tear gas involved healthy young men in military settings, which could help explain why menstrual and other reproductive health effects have gone undocumented.
Alsetex and Nobel Sport, two leading suppliers of tear gas grenades to French law enforcement, did not respond to requests for comment.
The Interior Ministry says no published scientific studies show that CS causes menstrual changes or miscarriages. It said other effects of tear gas generally resolve within hours, although it acknowledged that some longer-lasting symptoms affecting the skin and eyes ‘cannot be ruled out’.
“Some other possible effects in the body have been suggested, but not demonstrated,” it said.
The ministry said it conducted several studies in 2021 and 2022 assessing individual exposure to tear gas, particularly among law enforcement personnel. It did not respond to an AP request for copies.