Bangladesh on the boil: Hasina's return and the unfinished battle for political legitimacy

As Sheikh Hasina prepares to return from India, fresh violence, mass arrests and prison overcrowding are testing whether Bangladesh’s new government can deliver accountability without deepening political exclusion.

Sheikh Hasina's declared intention to return from India in December has become the immediate flashpoint for the unrest. File Photo: ANI
9 min read  |  Published: 21 Nov 2026

Bangladesh's prisons are holding nearly three times their official capacity. More than 50 residential structures have reportedly been torched in Narail, including properties linked to the Awami League. Political tensions are escalating across the country. And Sheikh Hasina has not even returned.

Two years after the uprising that forced the former prime minister into exile, Bangladesh is once again confronting the politics of violence and retaliation.

But this time, the unrest is unfolding under an elected government that came to power promising a break from the country's troubled political past.

Hasina's declared intention to return from India in December has become the immediate flashpoint.

Yet the deeper question is whether Bangladesh is moving towards a democratic reset or returning to the familiar cycle of political exclusion, confrontation and revenge.

A return fraught with consequences

Hasina's proposed return carries extraordinary legal and political complications.

The former prime minister, who fled to India on August 5, 2024, faces a death sentence imposed in absentia by Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal over crimes against humanity linked to the deadly crackdown on the student-led uprising. She denies responsibility and disputes the proceedings.

Her representatives have sought travel documents to facilitate her return, but the government in Dhaka maintains that the matter should be handled through the extradition process. No date for her return has been confirmed.

Yet her announcement has already changed the political atmosphere.

The Awami League called a nationwide shutdown on November 19 amid reports of crude bomb explosions, arson and clashes across several districts.

In Narail, the killing of two Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) activists following an attack on a procession was followed by retaliatory violence. A local fire official reported that more than 50 residential structures belonging to approximately 20 to 25 households were destroyed, although the local administration gave a lower assessment.

Properties associated with Awami League figures were among those targeted.

The violence illustrates how quickly Bangladesh's political rivalries can move beyond party leadership and engulf ordinary families.

For Prime Minister Tarique Rahman, the immediate challenge is restoring order without allowing the state's response to resemble the repression that helped bring down Hasina.

The unfinished legacy of 2024

The present confrontation cannot be understood without examining the uprising that ended Hasina's 15-year rule.

What began as student protests against government employment quotas in July 2024 developed into a nationwide movement against an administration accused of authoritarianism, suppressing dissent and weakening democratic institutions.

The crackdown was devastating.

A United Nations (UN) investigation estimated that as many as 1,400 people were killed during the July-August violence and documented serious human rights violations involving the former government and its security apparatus.

Accountability for those deaths remains essential.

But the question now is whether Bangladesh can deliver justice without allowing political affiliation itself to become grounds for punishment.

The country's prison crisis has added urgency to that debate.

Official figures from October showed 130,128 inmates against a capacity of just 45,186. The overcrowding is a serious institutional problem, although the figures do not establish how many detainees are imprisoned for political reasons.

Concerns over arbitrary arrests, prolonged pretrial detention and due process involving Awami League members have further complicated the political environment.

Justice for the victims of 2024 must remain a priority. But credible accountability requires individual responsibility, fair trials and protection against collective punishment.

An election that did not settle everything

The February 2026 parliamentary election brought the Bangladesh Nationalist Party to power, with Tarique Rahman becoming prime minister and Jamaat-e-Islami emerging as the principal parliamentary opposition.

The election marked a significant return to elected government following the interim administration led by Muhammad Yunus.

Yet the Awami League, one of Bangladesh's historically dominant political parties, was barred from contesting.

That exclusion remains central to the country's unresolved political divisions.

For supporters of the restrictions, the Awami League's role in the 2024 crackdown makes accountability a prerequisite for its rehabilitation.

For critics, excluding a major political organisation from electoral competition raises questions about the long-term inclusiveness of the democratic transition.

These concerns cannot be resolved by dismissing either side.

The Awami League must confront the abuses committed during its years in power. Equally, Bangladesh must eventually address how citizens who continue to support the party can participate in democratic politics.

A stable political order cannot depend indefinitely on the exclusion of its adversaries.

India's difficult diplomatic dilemma

Hasina's continued presence in India has added another dimension to the crisis.

New Delhi maintained close relations with her government, particularly on security cooperation, connectivity and regional stability.

Her removal fundamentally changed that relationship.

India now faces the challenge of maintaining ties with a BNP-led government while hosting its most prominent political rival.

Bangladesh has sought Hasina's extradition, while India has maintained that the request is being examined under applicable legal procedures.

The latest unrest has intensified diplomatic sensitivities, with Rahman accusing Awami League figures operating from abroad of encouraging instability and raising allegations concerning India.

Those allegations require evidence and should not be treated as established facts.

Nevertheless, Hasina's presence has become a source of friction between two countries whose economic and strategic interests remain closely connected.

For India, continuing to host her carries diplomatic consequences. Extraditing her would raise difficult legal and political questions.

Neither choice is straightforward.

Can Bangladesh break the cycle?

Bangladesh's political history has repeatedly been shaped by confrontation between the Awami League and the BNP.

Disputed elections, opposition boycotts, mass protests and allegations of repression have weakened public confidence in democratic institutions.

The 2024 uprising appeared to offer an opportunity to break that cycle.

But removing an entrenched government and building a durable democratic system are two very different achievements.

The Rahman administration must now demonstrate that it can maintain security without suppressing legitimate dissent, ensure accountability without political retaliation and govern amid mounting economic pressures.

The Awami League faces an equally difficult reckoning. Its political rehabilitation cannot depend solely on Hasina's return. It must confront the legacy of the 2024 crackdown and establish whether it can rebuild public trust.

For Bangladesh, the stakes extend well beyond the future of one former prime minister.

Hasina may return in December, or her legal and diplomatic difficulties may keep her in India for much longer.

But the deeper political challenge will remain.

Bangladesh has demonstrated that it can remove a powerful government. The harder test is whether it can build a democracy in which justice does not become political revenge, opposition does not automatically mean exclusion, and every change of government does not threaten to reopen the country's deepest divisions.

To advertise here,contact us