Gukesh vs Sindarov: More than a world title, India's champion fights for legitimacy

Garry Kasparov and Magnus Carlsen, have played a significant role in shaping the debate over Gukesh's place in chess history.

Indian Chess player D Gukesh. Photo: ANI
8 min read  |  Published: 22 Nov 2026

When India's D Gukesh became the youngest World Chess Champion at 18 in December 2024, he was at the peak of his powers. Two years later, as he prepares to defend his title against Uzbekistan's Javokhir Sindarov, Gukesh is at the lowest ebb of his career.

Not many among the chess elites favour Gukesh for the title this time. There are two obvious sides to that logic. The first is that Gukesh's form has declined sharply since winning the title in December 2024. The second, like the other face of a coin, is the contrasting rise of Sindarov, making him possibly the strongest classical player in business.

Then there is a third reason why some of the big names in the game don't give Gukesh a chance against Sindarov, and it has nothing to do with either player's form: They never accepted the boy from Chennai as the legitimate world champion in the first place.

The men responsible: Kasparov and Carlsen

Two men could be held responsible for delegitimising Gukesh's ascension: Former champions Garry Kasparov and Magnus Carlsen.

Six-time champion Kasparov famously said that the history of the world championship match began with Wilhelm Steinitz, the first champion, and ended with Carlsen, who abdicated his throne in 2021 after winning it for a fifth straight time. In his defence, Kasparov has not specifically delegitimised Gukesh; rather, anyone who has ascended to the throne in Carlsen's absence. By that admission, even Gukesh's predecessor Ding should find an Asterix affixed to his name in Kasparov's book.

Norwegian Carlsen is the highest-rated player ever, with a peak Elo of 2896, and has not relinquished his World No 1 status since 2011. His decision to step away from the classical world championship was shaped by his lack of motivation. He defeated Viswanathan Anand convincingly for his first two classical titles, got the better of Sergey Karjakin and Fabiano Caruana in tie-breakers for the next two and signed off with a dominating display against Ian Nepomniachtchi.

Gukesh's maiden triumph, while historic, was nothing as convincing as Carlsen's. Gukesh was 18 when he dethroned Ding Liren of China to become the youngest World Champion. He lost the opening game before equalising by winning the third game. He had destiny in his control by winning game 11, then let it slip by losing game 12, and it took a blunder from Ding in the final classical game (14) for him to triumph.

Carlsen has been quite blunt in dismissing Gukesh as his successor. Though he congratulated Gukesh after his triumph, Carlsen refused to regard the young Indian as worthy of the top position. "Is he the best player in the world? Remains to be seen. But is he a worthy world champion by, you know, what we measure that as, yeah, I think he certainly is," Carlsen said last May.

The ‘underdog’ champion

Why does Gukesh not invoke the same respect that his compatriot Viswanathan Anand did? Is it because Vishy won five classical world titles and was the only Indian to be World No 1? Vishy would certainly count among the greats of the game, and might even feature in the GOAT debate shortlist. Gukesh, on the other hand, has quite a distance to travel.

Carlsen regards Sindarov as a more rounded player, and has said he “doesn't have any obvious weaknesses”.

Kasparov feels Gukesh has a slightly better chance against Sindarov because of his experience, having played in one championship match. Carlsen, though, has bet on Sindarov, partly based on his studious understanding of the two players' strengths, and perhaps Gukesh's apparent weakness. "I don't think it's a secret to most people that his (Gukesh) evaluations are way too optimistic. That kind of makes him take way more chances than he should. I think especially now that his confidence hasn't been too high, he just tries to do a little bit too much," Carlsen recently said.

Gukesh's form has certainly not helped his cause, as he has not won a single tournament since dethroning Ding 24 months ago. His Elo rating has also dropped significantly, by over 70 points since then. He finished joint-last in the Prague Masters and Norway Chess this year.

In contrast, Sindarov has grown from strength to strength. During the same period, Sindarov's rating soared, reaching a career-high 2782 and a ranking of No 4. Gukesh's rankings fell like being dragged by gravity, reaching a lowly 26th going into the match. The difference in their ranking and ratings is the most glaring gap ever between a champion and his challenger in the history of the championship.

Sindarov clinched the World Cup and went undefeated to triumph in the FIDE Candidates that made him the challenger to Gukesh's title. If all this wasn't cool enough, Sindarov flew to the US to cheer Uzbekistan in the FIFA World Cup and often plays Counter-Strike to relax.

On top of it all, Sindarov's performance rating of about 2812 is arguably the best among leading players this year.

For Gukesh, the bar is higher than many believe he could reach. It is an overwhelming proposition, but the setting is just about perfect because now, if he triumphs, he wouldn't simply be retaining his title but would be making a solid case for himself as a legitimate world champion, which even Carlsen might have to approve.

To advertise here,contact us